FORECLOSURE vs. SHORTSALE

ISSUE

Credit Score: 

• Foreclosure will probably lower your FICO score from 250 to 300 points and will affect your credit score for 3 plus years
• With a successful short sale, only late payments on mortgage will show and after sale, the mortgage is usually reported "paid as agreed", "paid as negotiated" or "settled" with a 50 point score hit for 12 to 18 months

Credit History:

• A foreclosure remains as a public record on a person's credit history for 10 years or more
• A short sale is not reported on a person's credit history.

Current Employment:

• Employers have the right and regularly check the credit of employees in sensitive positions; a foreclosure may be grounds for reassignment or termination.  If a person is a police officer, a military member or working for a government agency such as the CIA, any security clearances will be revoked and the person reassigned or terminated.
• On its own, a short sale is usually not reported on a credit report and will likely not affect employment

Future Employment:

• Many employers require a credit check of all job applicants and a foreclosure will likely preclude hiring.
• A short sale is not reported and should have no effect.

Deficiency Judgement:

• In South Carolina, the bank has the right to pursue a deficiency judgement and chances are they will.  As foreclosed homes sell at lowers prices and the market is still declining, the result may be a higher judgement.
• In a short sale, it may be possible to convince the lender to fore go their right to pursue a deficiency judgement.  Short sales often sell close to market value, making any deficiency judgement lower.

Insurance:

• Insurance companies are now checking credit records and a foreclosure will likely boost car insurance rates and other types of insurance as well, such as a renter's policy
• A short sale is not reported and should have no effect

Loans:

• A foreclosure makes one ineligible for a Fannie Mae backed mortgage for 5 years; other types of mortgages will have a higher perhaps prohibitive rate
• A successful short sale generates a 2 year waiting period for a Fannie Mae backed mortgage and likely will not affect other loans as it's not reported.  However, if asked, a borrow should answer truthfully.

So, in every instance, it's worth it to make every attempt to work with your lender to avoid a foreclosure, no matter how difficult that may be.  Start early.